The
Minnesota Vikings season came to a crashing end on Saturday night after falling to the rival
Green Bay Packers 24-10. Despite the season ending on a down note, it was a remarkable season for many reasons, and had one big error that
might have made a difference last night.
That one big error? I think they should have kept
Sage Rosenfels as their backup QB and switched
Joe Webb to WR. This move would have helped in three ways, and I can't really think of a bad thing it would have brought. Joe Webb is NOT an NFL QB. Granted, he didn't play any meaningful snaps during the season, so the backup QB spot was mostly an afterthought through the season. However, having Rosenfels as the backup QB could have done a few things for the Vikings this year. It could have given
Christian Ponder a voice of reason on the sidelines. Yes, the Vikings have a QB coach, but as in any job, while any coach or manager an help someone grow, having a peer that can share their experience is such a positive growth tool, and was something Ponder didn't have in Webb and would have had in Rosenfels. It also could have meant
Leslie Fraiser wouldn't have been afraid to pull Ponder during one or two of his horrific games he struggled through. I'm not saying he would have replaced Ponder as the starting QB, but to give Ponder a chance to watch, learn, and find his focus again could have been good for him. And of course, it could have meant the Vikings could have still had an NFL QB ready to start in the playoff game against the Packers. Sure, there is a very good chance it would not have changed the result, but I am very confident that the Vikings chances of winning the game would have been much higher if Rosenfels would have been the backup QB instead of Webb.
The other side of that coin is keeping Rosenfels could have also move Webb to Wide Receiver. Joe Webb is a fantastic athlete. He is not an NFL QB. The Vikings biggest weakness this year was at WR, and this one little move of keeping Rosenfels and moving Webb to WR would have killed two birds with one stone. Yes, Webb would be inexperienced at WR. But putting his athletic abilities on the field, giving him a chance to be the deep threat, to run bubble-screens, to run a few wild-cat plays, to be a red-zone target that can jump through the roof to catch a high pass at the back of the end-zone. I don't see how any of those things wouldn't have helped the Vikings maybe even win one or two more games during the season, and possible still be playing in this years playoffs.
OK, having said that, this year was a FANTASTIC year. There is absolutely no way anyone could have expected a playoff team this year. I think 98% of Vikings fans would have been happy with the improvement if they won 7 games. But they over shot those expectations to win 10 games and make the playoffs. So here are some key players that helped make this a season of beating expectations:
Rick Spielman had a fantastic first season in his General Manager position. The draft was insanely successful and saw many players have huge impacts on the season.
Matt Kalil,
Harrison Smith, and
Blair Walsh are all going to be studs for many years to come.
Josh Robinson,
Rhett Elison, and
Jarius Wright are all going to be the type of roll players playoff teams need to be successful. Yes, Spielman didn't get the results he wanted by signing
John Carlson or
Jerome Simpson. I don't think those were bad decisions, they were good decisions that just didn't work out. Spielman filled a lot of holes in the roster last off season. If he can find a WR or two, a linebacker, and a backup QB to push Ponder, and have another very successful draft, this Vikings team is going to be tough to beat going forward.
Leslie Fraiser has turned a franchise that is used to being full of "character" moments (love boat, wizzinator) into a franchise that talks about football. His leadership and demeanor have greatly revitalized the franchise. Many in the national media compare him to
Tony Dungy. I think a more appropriate comparison would be
Bud Grant. And I look forward to Frasier leading this team into the future.
Bill Musgrave and
Alan Williams. Bill Musgrave has one major issue he needs to fix. He out-thinks himself too often. I think when Ponder was struggling, he didn't call games in a way to help out. Those last four games of the season though, he was really dialed in and called outstanding games. But then again in that game yesterday, I think since he was stuck with Joe Webb at QB, he should have just kept running QB options instead of having Webb throw the ball as much as he did. The first drive was perfect. The rest of the game he called a different game. But the most overlooked part of Musgrave is that Adrian Peterson owes much of his success this year to the game plans and the running schemes Musgrave put together. Meanwhile, Alan Williams oversaw a defense that kept getting better as the season went on. As he learned on the job, as he learned what his players could do, as his players developed, our defense really started stepping up and kept us in games so the Vikings could win despite not being able to throw the ball. I'm excited about what he can do going forward.
And of course, there is
Adrian Peterson. Good gawd, what a season that guy had. To do what he did when everyone knew he was getting the rock is just amazing. Odds are he will never have a season like this again, but I'm going to be the first person on his Drive for 25(00) bus next season.
Every team in the league, even the eventual Super Bowl Champion, will look back and see mistakes they will try to fix. It's my opinion the Vikings biggest one was the moves made with Rosenfels and Webb. Even with that move, the improvement from 3 wins to 10 wins is just incredible. And I have no problems giving this season a standing ovation.
