I'm probably a little tardy with a blog about the Vikings draft, but I wanted to let this settle in for a bit before commenting on it. Most "experts" say it takes three-years to evaluate a draft, but then none of these "experts" never tell us how anyone drafted three years ago. At the end of this blog I'm going to actually do that with the Vikings draft from 2007. Before I get to that, lets look at this 2010 Vikings draft.
Chris Cook, a CB from West Virginia was the Vikings first pick of the draft. I think this was their worst pick of the draft. It's my feeling that they gambled in trading down that one of their top CB's would still be there and they all got gobbled up. I think they could have traded down again and still got Cook if that is who they wanted. The highest pre-draft ranking I saw for Cook was a 46th pick. The Vikings took him 34th. Cook does fill a need since both starting CB's for the Vikings are coming off injuries, but I'm thinking he's going to be strictly a special teams player.
The Vikings next pick was Toby Gerhart, a RB from Stanford. I absolutely LOVE this pick. Taking him at #51 might have been a little bit of a reach, but this pick fits perfectly for the Vikings. Probably the biggest loss the Vikings suffered in the off-season was losing Chester Taylor (including the double impact of losing him to a division rival). No offence to Taylor, but I think Gerhart comes in a does a better job than Chester did this past season. Toby can run, block and catch just as well as Chester did, but Toby will also punish defenders. I can't imagine defensive players being too happy about having to try tackling Adrian Peterson, and then when AP takes a break they then have to face Gerhart.
Everson Griffen, DE, USC was the Vikings 3rd pick in the draft (taken in the 4th round). This is another pick I love. Most people gave him first-round grades, in fact the lowest grade I saw given to him pre-draft was as the 23rd best prospect. The Vikings took him with the 100th pick, which totally makes up for the reach on Cook. He fell to the 4th round mostly from teams doubting his drive and determination. From the looks of it, that could be a legitimate concern, but I find it hard to believe anyone can work with a guy like Jared Allen every day and not have some of Allen's drive rub off on you. When Griffen is on, people have been comparing him to Dwight Freeney. Anytime you can draft someone in the 4th round that is compared to Freeney I'm thinking you got yourself a pretty good pick.
The Vikings next pick was Chris DeGeare, OL, Wake Forrest. Uh... ok. As good as the Griffen pick was, this one makes me scratch my head. I never saw this guy ranked higher than 262nd in anyone pre-draft rankings. The Vikings took him at 161. That is just an incredible reach. And then lets consider how un-intelligent this DeGeare is. He missed a year of football because he couldn't figure out his school work. His scouting report say he has never been able to figure out the twists and stunts defensive linemen pull. Great. Welcome to the NFL DeGeare.
For their 5th selection, the Vikings took Nate Tripplet, LB, Minnesota. This pick right here might have been the worst pick in the entire draft. By any team. I don't think anyone in the world had him ranked in their top 500 players. In fact, in the five places I found that had players ranked at least 500 deep he wasn't listed on any of them. And the Vikings used their #167 pick on him.
Joe Webb was the Vikings next pick, and possibly the most confusing pick they made, at least initially. Most places had Webb listed as a QB. He was listed as a QB on the NFL.coms draft tracker. Ok, the Vikings obviously need a QB. And Webb did something in his last two seasons that no QB had ever done in the history of college football by passing for 2,000 yards and rushing for 1,000 yards two seasons in a row. Most of his scouting report basically made him a Tavarious Jackson clone. Why would the Vikings take a QB that is pretty much exactly like one that has already failed? Then it turns out they took him to play WR, which is where he played his first year in college, and now it's looking like it could be one very nice pick. Just like Randy Moss when the Vikings drafted him, Webb has a freakish combo of size and athleticism. How athletic is he? His college coach was also the college coach of one Bo Jackson. That coach said Joe is in Bo's league. In Webb, the Vikings got a 6'3" 223 pound WR that can run a 4.4 in the 40 yard dash, and a 42-1/2" vertical. He only had 30 receptions that one year he played WR in college so he might be a little raw out there. But getting this kind of potential with a 6th round pick is very much worth the gamble. Not to mention I'm already getting giddy about a possible wild-cat formation with Webb at QB, Percy and AP in the backfield. That could drive some defenses nuts. After the initial confusion, I'm now excited for this pick and hoping he turns out.
The Vikings 7th selection was Mickey Shuler, TE, Penn State. I think this pick was also a bit of a reach. He does fit the blocking TE mold pretty well, and that's a spot the Vikings will need to cover as Jimmy Kliensasser is getting up there in experience. I'm not sure this pick makes the team except for maybe being on the practice squad.
Ryan D'Imperio, LB, Rutgers was the Vikings 8th and final selection in this 2010 NFL draft. This is yet another pick that I'm sure would have not been drafted by anyone else. I think he has the same odds of winning the lottery as making the team.
So, over the past couple of years, the Vikings have done remarkably well in the draft. All seven picks last year started and contributed. This year... I love two of the picks (Gerhart and Griffen). I think those two could possibly turn in performances that overshadow how bad the rest of the draft was. I think two other picks will contribute (Webb and Cook). I'm at a loss for words at how bad the rest of the selections were. But then again, I'm a restaurant manager. Maybe the guys that get paid to do this knew what they were doing again and we'll see all seven do well.
Now, lets look back at the 2007 Vikings draft.
1. Adrian Peterson. All-world stud. Grade A+.
2. Sidney Rice. All-pro WR last year. Grade A.
3. Marcus McCauley. Held his own during his rookie season, has disappeared since then. No longer on the team. Grade D+.
4. Brian Robison. Very solid backup on a very good defensive line. Grade B-
5. Aundrae Allison. Never made it above 4th WR. No longer on the team. Grade D.
6. Rufus Alexander. Failed. Grade F.
7. Tyler Thigpen. Tyler started 14 games in 2008. For the Chiefs. Nice pick, the failure here was trying to sneak him onto the practice squad. Grade C-
8. Chandler Williams. Failed. Grade F.
Adding it all up, for the 2007 draft I'd give the Vikings a final grade of a C+/B-.